States Of Open Quantum Systems Research Articles

Effective Hamiltonian theory: An approximation to the equilibrium state of open quantum systems

Effective Hamiltonian theory: An approximation to the equilibrium state of open quantum systems

Dynamics of a driven open double two-level system and its entanglement generation

We investigate the dynamics of the driven open double two-level system by deriving a driven Markovian master equation based on the Lewis-Riesenfeld invariant theory. The transitions induced by coupling to the heat reservoir occur between the instantaneous eigenstates of the Lewis-Riesenfeld invariant. Therefore, different driving protocols associated with corresponding Lewis-Riesenfeld invariants result in different open system dynamics and symmetries. In particular, we show that since the instantaneous steady state of the driven double two-level system is one of eigenstates of the Lewis-Riesenfeld invariant at ultralow reservoir temperature, the inverse engineering method based on the Lewis-Riesenfeld invariants has a good performance in rapidly preparing the quantum state of open quantum systems. As an example, a perfect entangled state is generated by means of the inverse engineering method.

Relaxation to a Parity-Time Symmetric Generalized Gibbs Ensemble after a Quantum Quench in a Driven-Dissipative Kitaev Chain

The construction of the generalized Gibbs ensemble, to which isolated integrable quantum many-body systems relax after a quantum quench, is based upon the principle of maximum entropy. In contrast, there are no universal and model-independent laws that govern the relaxation dynamics and stationary states of open quantum systems, which are subjected to Markovian drive and dissipation. Yet, as we show, relaxation of driven-dissipative systems after a quantum quench can, in fact, be determined by a maximum entropy ensemble, if the Liouvillian that generates the dynamics of the system has parity-time symmetry. Focusing on the specific example of a driven-dissipative Kitaev chain, we show that, similar to isolated integrable systems, the approach to a parity-time symmetric generalized Gibbs ensemble becomes manifest in the relaxation of local observables and the dynamics of subsystem entropies. In contrast, the directional pumping of fermion parity, which is induced by nontrivial non-Hermitian topology of the Kitaev chain, represents a phenomenon that is unique to relaxation dynamics in driven-dissipative systems. Upon increasing the strength of dissipation, parity-time symmetry is broken at a finite critical value, which thus constitutes a sharp dynamical transition that delimits the applicability of the principle of maximum entropy. We show that these results, which we obtain for the specific example of the Kitaev chain, apply to broad classes of noninteracting fermionic models, and we discuss their generalization to a noninteracting bosonic model and an interacting spin chain.

Floquet States in Open Quantum Systems

In Floquet engineering, periodic driving is used to realize novel phases of matter that are inaccessible in thermal equilibrium. For this purpose, the Floquet theory provides us a recipe for obtaining a static effective Hamiltonian. Although many existing works have treated closed systems, it is important to consider the effect of dissipation, which is ubiquitous in nature. Understanding the interplay of periodic driving and dissipation is a fundamental problem of nonequilibrium statistical physics that is receiving growing interest because of the fact that experimental advances have allowed us to engineer dissipation in a controllable manner. In this review, we give a detailed exposition on the formalism of quantum master equations for open Floquet systems and highlight recent work investigating whether equilibrium statistical mechanics applies to Floquet states.

Nonequilibrium stationary states of quantum non-Hermitian lattice models

We show how generic non-Hermitian tight-binding lattice models can be realized in an unconditional, quantum-mechanically consistent manner by constructing an appropriate open quantum system. We focus on the quantum steady states of such models for both fermionic and bosonic systems. Surprisingly, key features and spatial structures in the steady state cannot be simply understood from the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian alone. Using the 1D Hatano-Nelson model as a paradigmatic example, we show that the steady state has a marked sensitivity to boundary conditions. This dependence however is qualitatively and quantitatively distinct from the non-Hermitian skin effect, and has no simple connection to non-Hermitian topology. Further, particle statistics play an unexpected role: the steady-state density profile is dramatically different for fermions versus bosons. Our work highlights the key role of fluctuations in quantum realizations of non-Hermitian dynamics, and provides a starting point for future work on engineered steady states of open quantum systems.

Purity as a measure of entanglement between two distant mechanical mirrors

Characterizing and quantifying quantum entanglement in states of open quantum systems are at the heart of quantum information theory. In this work, we study the mixedness and entanglement of a two-mode symmetrical Gaussian state evolving in a thermal Markovian environment. The considered state is that of two movable end-mirrors of two distant Fabry–Pérot cavities coupled via a two-mode squeezed light and driven by coherent lasers. We use the logarithmic negativity to consistently quantify the degree of entanglement between the two mechanical modes. The purity is employed as a witness of mixedness and characterize of entanglement in the two-mode mechanical bi-partition. By comparing the behavior of the logarithmic negativity with that of the purity under the effect of various parameters and based on the entanglement classification established in [G. Adesso, A. Serafini and F. Illuminati, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 087901 (2004)], we found that the purity can be used as a characterize and measure of entanglement in the two-mode symmetrical state when the squeezing parameter is fixed. The effects of thermal noise, squeezing and optomechanical coupling are also discussed in detail.

Controlling the dynamics of dissipationless localized bound states in open quantum systems with periodic driving fields

In this paper, we study the exact dynamics of open quantum systems in the presence of dissipationless localized bound states and periodic driving fields. We show that different from the static adjustment of the system parameters to control the existence of localized bound states in open quantum systems, the periodic driving can either modulate the dynamics of the existing localized bound states or make some of them disappear due to the sideband generation from the driving that makes electrons transit between the localized bound states and continuous states. This analysis is also different from the widely used Floquet theory in the study of the driving effect on open system dynamics. We also find the conditions for the protection of the dissipationless localized bound states from the driving and for the manipulation of quantum coherence between localized bound states using the driving. The results for the dynamics of localized bound states have a potential application in controlling the quantum state against decoherence for the sake of its sensitivity to the fundamental frequency of the driving field and its strength.

Variational Quantum Algorithms for the Steady States of Open Quantum SystemsSupported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2016YFA0301700), and the Anhui Initiative in Quantum Information Technologies (Grant No. AHY080000).

The solutions of the problems related to open quantum systems have attracted considerable interest. We propose a variational quantum algorithm to find the steady state of open quantum systems. In this algorithm, we employ parameterized quantum circuits to prepare the purification of the steady state and define the cost function based on the Lindblad master equation, which can be efficiently evaluated with quantum circuits. We then optimize the parameters of the quantum circuit to find the steady state. Numerical simulations are performed on the one-dimensional transverse field Ising model with dissipative channels. The result shows that the fidelity between the optimal mixed state and the true steady state is over 99%. This algorithm is derived from the natural idea of expressing mixed states with purification and it provides a reference for the study of open quantum systems.

Response theory for nonequilibrium steady states of open quantum systems

We introduce a response theory for open quantum systems within nonequilibrium steady-states subject to a Hamiltonian perturbation. Working in the weak system-bath coupling regime, our results are derived within the Lindblad-Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan formalism. We find that the response of the system to a small perturbation is not simply related to a correlation function within the system, unlike traditional linear response theory in closed systems or expectations from the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. In limiting cases, when the perturbation is small relative to the coupling to the surroundings or when it does not lead to a change of the eigenstructure of the system, a perturbative expansion exists where the response function is related to a sum of a system correlation functions and additional forces induced by the surroundings. Away from these limiting regimes however, the secular approximation results in a singular response that cannot be captured within the traditional approach, but can be described by reverting to a microscopic Hamiltonian description. These findings are illustrated by explicit calculations in coupled qubits and anharmonic oscillators in contact with bosonic baths at different temperatures.

A quantum algorithm for the direct estimation of the steady state of open quantum systems

Simulating the dynamics and the non-equilibrium steady state of an open quantum system are hard computational tasks on conventional computers. For the simulation of the time evolution, several efficient quantum algorithms have recently been developed. However, computing the non-equilibrium steady state as the long-time limit of the system dynamics is often not a viable solution, because of exceedingly long transient features or strong quantum correlations in the dynamics. Here, we develop an efficient quantum algorithm for the direct estimation of averaged expectation values of observables on the non-equilibrium steady state, thus bypassing the time integration of the master equation. The algorithm encodes the vectorized representation of the density matrix on a quantum register, and makes use of quantum phase estimation to approximate the eigenvector associated to the zero eigenvalue of the generator of the system dynamics. We show that the output state of the algorithm allows to estimate expectation values of observables on the steady state. Away from critical points, where the Liouvillian gap scales as a power law of the system size, the quantum algorithm performs with exponential advantage compared to exact diagonalization.

Fate of fractional quantum Hall states in open quantum systems: Characterization of correlated topological states for the full Liouvillian

Despite previous extensive analysis of open quantum systems described by the Lindblad equation, it is unclear whether correlated topological states, such as fractional quantum Hall states, are maintained even in the presence of the jump term. In this paper, we introduce the pseudo-spin Chern number of the Liouvillian which is computed by twisting the boundary conditions only for one of the subspaces of the doubled Hilbert space. The existence of such a topological invariant elucidates that the topological properties remain unchanged even in the presence of the jump term which does not close the gap of the effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian (obtained by neglecting the jump term). In other words, the topological properties are encoded into an effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian rather than the full Liouvillian. This is particularly useful when the jump term can be written as a strictly block-upper (-lower) triangular matrix in the doubled Hilbert space, in which case the presence or absence of the jump term does not affect the spectrum of the Liouvillian. With the pseudo-spin Chern number, we address the characterization of fractional quantum Hall states with two-body loss but without gain, elucidating that the topology of the non-Hermitian fractional quantum Hall states is preserved even in the presence of the jump term. This numerical result also supports the use of the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian which significantly reduces the numerical cost. Similar topological invariants can be extended to treat correlated topological states for other spatial dimensions and symmetry (e.g., one-dimensional open quantum systems with inversion symmetry), indicating the high versatility of our approach.

Quantum Neimark-Sacker bifurcation

Recently, it has been demonstrated that asymptotic states of open quantum system can undergo qualitative changes resembling pitchfork, saddle-node, and period doubling classical bifurcations. Here, making use of the periodically modulated open quantum dimer model, we report and investigate a quantum Neimark-Sacker bifurcation. Its classical counterpart is the birth of a torus (an invariant curve in the Poincaré section) due to instability of a limit cycle (fixed point of the Poincaré map). The quantum system exhibits a transition from unimodal to bagel shaped stroboscopic distributions, as for Husimi representation, as for observables. The spectral properties of Floquet map experience changes reminiscent of the classical case, a pair of complex conjugated eigenvalues approaching a unit circle. Quantum Monte-Carlo wave function unraveling of the Lindblad master equation yields dynamics of single trajectories on “quantumtorus” and allows for quantifying it by rotation number. The bifurcation is sensitive to the number of quantum particles that can also be regarded as a control parameter.

Variational Neural-Network Ansatz for Steady States in Open Quantum Systems.

We present a general variational approach to determine the steady state of open quantum lattice systems via a neural-network approach. The steady-state density matrix of the lattice system is constructed via a purified neural-network Ansatz in an extended Hilbert space with ancillary degrees of freedom. The variational minimization of cost functions associated to the master equation can be performed using a Markov chain MonteCarlo sampling. As a first application and proof of principle, we apply the method to the dissipative quantum transverse Ising model.

Coherence, entanglement, and quantumness in closed and open systems with conserved charge, with an application to many-body localization

While the scaling of entanglement in a quantum system can be used to distinguish many-body quantum phases, it is usually hard to quantify the amount of entanglement in mixed states of open quantum systems, while measuring entanglement experimentally, even for the closed systems, requires in general quantum state tomography. In this work we show how to remedy this situation in system with a fixed or conserved charge, e.g., density or magnetization, due to an emerging relation between quantum correlations and coherence. First, we show how, in these cases, the presence of multipartite entanglement or quantumness can be faithfully witnessed simply by detecting coherence in the quantum system, while bipartite entanglement or bipartite quantum discord are implied by asymmetry (block coherence) in the system. Second, we prove that the relation between quantum correlations and coherence is also quantitative. Namely, we establish upper and lower bounds on the amount of multipartite and bipartite entanglement in a many-body system with a fixed local charge, in terms of the amount of coherence and asymmetry present in the system. Importantly, both for pure and mixed quantum states, these bounds are expressed as closed formulas, and furthermore, for bipartite entanglement, are experimentally accessible by means of the multiple quantum coherence spectra. In particular, in one-dimensional systems, our bounds may detect breaking of the area law of entanglement entropy. We illustrate our results on the example of a many-body localized system, also in the presence of dephasing.

Fast trajectory tracking of the steady state of open quantum systems

We present a control strategy to speed up the steady-state tracking for open quantum systems governed by a time-dependent Markovian master equation. With this fast trajectory tracking strategy, the quantum state strictly follows the instantaneous steady state of open quantum systems and evolves into the target state without any fidelity loss. A compact expression for the counterdiabatic term is derived in terms of a superoperator formalism in Liouville space. To be specific, we utilize a universal method to transform the counterdiabatic superoperator into the ordinary operator form. It can be seen from the operator form that in addition to the coherent control field, an incoherent control is required for the fast trajectory tracking. The control strategy is successfully applied in two examples: One is a two-level quantum system with a time-dependent Hamiltonian coupling to a heat bath, the other is a two-level system following an isothermal process.

Signatures of many-body localization in steady states of open quantum systems

Many-body localization (MBL) is a result of the balance between interference-based Anderson localization and many-body interactions in an ultra-high dimensional Fock space. It is usually expected that dissipation is blurring interference and destroying that balance so that the asymptotic state of a system with an MBL Hamiltonian does not bear localization signatures. We demonstrate, within the framework of the Lindblad formalism, that the system can be brought into a steady state with non-vanishing MBL signatures. We use a set of dissipative operators acting on pairs of connected sites (or spins), and show that the difference between ergodic and MBL Hamiltonians is encoded in the imbalance, entanglement entropy, and level spacing characteristics of the density operator. An MBL system which is exposed to the combined impact of local dephasing and pairwise dissipation evinces localization signatures hitherto absent in the dephasing-outshaped steady state.

Equilibrium States in Open Quantum Systems.

The aim of this paper is to study the question of whether or not equilibrium states exist in open quantum systems that are embedded in at least two environments and are described by a non-Hermitian Hamilton operator . The eigenfunctions of contain the influence of exceptional points (EPs) and external mixing (EM) of the states via the environment. As a result, equilibrium states exist (far from EPs). They are different from those of the corresponding closed system. Their wavefunctions are orthogonal even though the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian.

Open system perspective on incoherent excitation of light-harvesting systems

The nature of excited states of open quantum systems produced by incoherent natural thermal light is analyzed based on a description of the quantum dynamical map. Natural thermal light is shown to generate long-lasting coherent dynamics because of (i) the super-Ohmic character of the radiation, and (ii) the absence of pure dephasing dynamics. In the presence of an environment, the long-lasting coherences induced by suddenly turned-on incoherent light dissipate and stationary coherences are established. As a particular application, dynamics in a subunit of the PC645 light-harvesting complex is considered where it is further shown that aspects of the energy pathways landscape depend on the nature of the exciting light and number of chromophores excited. Specifically, pulsed laser and natural broadband incoherent excitation induce significantly different energy transfer pathways. In addition, we discuss differences in perspective associated with the eigenstate versus site basis, and note an important difference in the phase of system coherences when coupled to blackbody radiation or when coupled to a phonon background. Finally, an appendix contains an open systems example of the loss of coherence as the turn-on time of the light assumes natural time scales.

Asymptotic Floquet states of open quantum systems: the role of interaction

When a periodically modulated many-body quantum system is weakly coupled to an environment, the combined action of these temporal modulations and dissipation steers the system towards a state characterized by a time-periodic density operator. To resolve this asymptotic non-equilibrium state at stroboscopic instants of time, we use the dissipative propagator over one period of modulations, ‘Floquet map’, and evaluate the stroboscopic density operator as its invariant. Particle interactions control properties of the map and thus the features of its invariant. In addition, the spectrum of the map provides insight into the system relaxation towards the asymptotic state and may help to understand whether it is possible (or not) to construct a stroboscopic time-independent Lindblad generator which mimics the action of the original time-dependent one. We illustrate the idea with a scalable many-body model, a periodically modulated Bose–Hubbard dimer. We contrast the relations between the interaction-induced bifurcations in a mean-field description with the numerically exact stroboscopic evolution and discuss the characteristics of the genuine quantum many-body state vs the characteristics of its mean-field counterpart.

Efficient steady-state solver for hierarchical quantum master equations.

Steady states play pivotal roles in many equilibrium and non-equilibrium open system studies. Their accurate evaluations call for exact theories with rigorous treatment of system-bath interactions. Therein, the hierarchical equations-of-motion (HEOM) formalism is a nonperturbative and non-Markovian quantum dissipation theory, which can faithfully describe the dissipative dynamics and nonlinear response of open systems. Nevertheless, solving the steady states of open quantum systems via HEOM is often a challenging task, due to the vast number of dynamical quantities involved. In this work, we propose a self-consistent iteration approach that quickly solves the HEOM steady states. We demonstrate its high efficiency with accurate and fast evaluations of low-temperature thermal equilibrium of a model Fenna-Matthews-Olson pigment-protein complex. Numerically exact evaluation of thermal equilibrium Rényi entropies and stationary emission line shapes is presented with detailed discussion.